Thought Leadership

To help turn around the trajectory of our economy and country, BLSA contributes to debates on important public policy issues facing South Africans. We cover a wide range of topics - from general economics to social policy issues such as gender rights and education.

BLSA commissions research from senior economists, policy analysts and academics to support the development of policy ideas. Opinion pieces and research reports are published and we welcome engagement via social media and other forums to advance these debates.

Content reflects the views of senior staff members or researchers, as well as board members, but should be seen as the work of the authors cited.

Make sure you don't miss any posts by subscribing to email alerts below.

BLSA CEO’s Weekly Newsletter – A crackdown on illicit trade and a push for stable councils

15/11/2026 | By Busisiwe Mavuso

  • Parks Tau’s track-and-trace system is a welcome but overdue response to illicit trade displacing R193bn of formal production.
  • The system will work only with active enforcement, and its costs must fall on lawbreakers, not compliant businesses.
  • Minister Hlabisa’s coalition guidelines are a welcome second-best while the Municipal Structures Amendment Bill sits before Parliament.
  • Parties governing 138 hung councils should publicly commit to the guidelines and publish their coalition agreements.

Last week the Minister of Trade, Industry and Competition, Parks Tau, published regulations for a track-and-trace system to be introduced next year. Business has been calling for government to act for years, and it is good to see action at last.

Manufacturers and importers of tobacco, liquor, pharmaceuticals, food and appliances will place a code on their goods that can be checked at points along the supply chain to confirm they are legitimate. The National Consumer Commission will hold the data. The SA Revenue Service (SARS), the Border Management Authority, the Department of Health, the SA Health Products Regulatory Authority and the National Regulator for Compulsory Specifications will all have access to it.

The illicit economy is a serious threat to the country. Modelling by Econometrix for the Consumer Goods Council of SA estimates that illicit trade displaces R193bn in formal production and more than 87,000 direct jobs across 12 sectors and costs the fiscus at least R68bn a year in tax. The cigarette industry is among the most severely affected, with an estimated 75% of cigarettes in South Africa sold illegally. British American Tobacco will close its Heidelberg factory, its last in the country, at the end of this year. The damage reaches much further – counterfeit pharmaceuticals, clothing, alcohol, manufactured goods and even timber are sold to unsuspecting consumers. That puts their safety at risk and undercuts businesses that pay their taxes and answer for the quality of their products.

Government has been slow to react to the threat. When illicit trade surged after Covid, business urged the authorities to act and proposed a barcoding system that had worked elsewhere. Those suggestions fell on deaf ears. Minister Tau deserves credit for breaking with that record.

The European Union shows what such a system can do for tobacco. There, 53 billion products have been traced in the first two years alone, with unverified goods stopped in their tracks. A global regime is being built under the international protocol to eliminate illicit trade in tobacco products, so goods will be traceable across borders, not just within them.

Such systems are not perfect. Tracking and tracing will require active policing to have any effect. The system will work only if it is checked against the production volumes that manufacturers report, and if SARS and the border agencies act on what the data shows – seizing goods, closing factories and prosecuting those responsible. It must also be run so that compliant producers do not carry costs that illicit operators avoid. The costs must sit on the shoulders of those who break the law, not those who abide by it.

It is too late to reverse the decision British American Tobacco has been forced to make. It is not too late to protect the industries still standing. Business stands ready to work with the department to make this system succeed.

+++

Last week the minister of cooperative governance and traditional affairs, Velenkosini Hlabisa, published the Guidelines for Stable Coalitions in Local Government. It is a welcome step. As I wrote last week, 138 municipalities – about two-thirds of councils – emerged from the local government elections without an outright majority. The leadership of those councils over the next five years will shape service delivery, investment and jobs across much of the country.

Stability is vital – workers and ratepayers alike require councils that can make decisions effectively and ensure the execution of turnaround plans. Those must be executed over years, by leaders who stay long enough to see them through. Where leadership must change, it should change without derailing work already under way. We cannot afford a repeat of Johannesburg, which has had 10 mayoral changes since 2016.

The guidelines are not binding. The law that would be – the Municipal Structures Amendment Bill – was approved by cabinet in August and is before Parliament, but it was not passed in time to govern the coalitions now being formed. That is a missed opportunity, because the Bill sets sensible rules for stable executive and political leadership in councils. The guidelines are a second-best substitute. They anticipate the legislation and give municipalities a way to start complying now. They also urge councils to amend their rules to prevent the abuse of motions of no confidence, which have been the main instrument of instability.

The guidelines set a bar against which voters can measure their representatives. But they help only as far as political parties agree to follow them. Every party in a coalition should commit publicly to the guidelines and publish its coalition agreement. That would show voters that parties are prepared to give up back-room deals in exchange for stability, and show business that it can rely on municipal leadership. Parliament, for its part, should remain focused on passing the bill so that the next round of coalition-building happens under rules with force. That would give business and voters confidence in their political leadership and democracy.

+++

BLSA is a business organisation that believes in South Africa’s future and shares the values set out in the Constitution. BLSA is committed to playing its part in creating a South Africa of increasing prosperity for all by harnessing the resources and capabilities of business in partnership with government and civil society to deliver economic growth, transformation and inclusion.    

+++

Last year, BLSA launched the BLSA Reform Tracker, an innovative online platform designed to monitor and evaluate the progress of key government reforms affecting the business environment and economic growth. The fifth BLSA Reform Tracker Quarterly Review, covering July to September 2026, shows that South Africa’s overall reform completion index rose to a record 72.5 from 71.3 in the previous quarter, 28.4% above the March 2024 baseline. Read the Quarterly Review for 1 July to 30 September here.